
By Kathy Shwiff
By a 7-2 vote, the Morris Township planning board this week approved Toll Brothers’ application to build a 118-unit townhome community at 300 Madison Ave.
Board members Edward Benoit and George Quillan voted no at Monday’s meeting.

Several board members said they had problems with various aspects of the project but pointed out they had no choice except to vote for it. The development is part of the Township’s fourth-round affordable housing plan, mandated by the state.
Liked this story? Get the next one first.
Free, 3x a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Toll Brothers did not require any variances, deviations or design waivers for the development, which would have 24 units, or 20 percent, deemed affordable housing. The other 94 units would be sold at market rates. All the units, in 16 buildings, would be for sale.
The community would be built on eight acres previously owned by JCP&L.
In public comments before the vote, residents again asked Toll Brothers to save some of the oldest and largest trees on the property.

Ariadne Monfalcone objected to the density of the development and said traffic from it would worsen what she called one of the most dangerous intersections in the township, at Old Turnpike and Punch Bowl roads. All entrances to the community are on those two roads, with none on Madison Avenue, which is a state highway.
She noted there have been several accidents at that intersection, including one involving a school bus.
Benoit called the development “a disservice to the town” and said Toll Brothers did little to comply with requests from board members to improve its design. The Township has a design ordinance but its specifications are considered to be recommendations, not requirements.
He has complained about the “stark” look of the sides of the three-story buildings that will face Old Turnpike Road. In response, Toll Brothers agreed to use stone to the top of the first floor.

The developer also promised to use cedar or a composite rather than vinyl on a six-foot fence along the western edge of the property after Benoit objected to the look of vinyl.
“I think the project could be so much better,” Benoit said Monday, contending the property is a premier location.
Both Benoit and board chairman Richard Bye showed photos they took on visits to Meridian Walk at Princeton, another Toll Brothers community.
Quillan said he was not convinced that the project met all the Township’s zoning requirements, arguing that the board has authority over grading changes. Toll Brothers plans to bring in 15 feet of fill near the intersection of Old Turnpike and Punch Bowl, then add a 44-foot building on top.

William “Bud” Ravitz, a Township committeeman who serves on the planning board, called the development “a good project in the best interest of the town” despite his dislike of some parts of the plan.

Toll Brothers representatives said landscaping plans for trees and bushes will improve the look of the community, especially as the trees mature. They promised a good-faith effort to use evergreen trees rather than trees that lose their leaves in cold weather after residents complained about plans to use deciduous trees.
Toll Brothers also revised the floor plans of the three-bedroom affordable housing units to include a second full bathroom.
Previously, Toll Brothers representatives testified that the stacked townhomes likely will cost from $600,000 to $800,000 and the three-story townhomes from $1.1 million to $1.2 million.
The affordable units, which will be scattered throughout the development, may cost between $50,000 and $220,000.
Giving Tuesday · Dec. 1
You just read local news. Double it.
No paywall, no billionaire. Just neighbors who chip in. Through Dec. 1, a Morristown neighbor will match every gift dollar for dollar, up to $10,000. Your $50 becomes $100 of local reporting.
Double my gift



