Judge says Madison must consider Drew Forest for affordable housing

The Drew Forest, August 2022. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Drew University has scored a partial victory against Madison in its legal fight to rezone the Drew Forest for high-density development.

In a six-page opinion issued on Friday, Superior Court Judge Stephan Hansbury directed the borough to update its analysis of vacant lands available for affordable housing, and to consider the Forest in those calculations.

Madison had thought it was immune from Mt. Laurel challenges for the next decade, because the court approved its affordable housing plan last year.

Superior Court Judge Stephan Hansbury at Aug, 19, 2022, hearing in the Drew v. Madison case. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

But Hansbury found that “a significant potential change to increase the amount of Mt. Laurel housing cannot be ignored by the court.” Drew envisions hundreds of market-rate units, subsidizing 20 percent for low- and moderate income residents.

Madison will have 45 days to submit its review — after Drew gives the borough a survey of the proposed acreage it seeks to develop. Then the court will schedule a status conference to decide what’s next.

Hansbury denied Drew’s request to mandate negotiations with the borough, and to appoint a special master to oversee such talks.

The university’s attempt to nullify Madison’s 2021 housing settlement also was rebuffed for a second time; killing the agreement could jeopardize other affordable housing projects in the pipeline, asserted the judge, who was called from retirement because of a shortage of jurists.

Although Drew has promoted itself as “the university in the forest,” it now says it must sell a portion of its 168-acre campus to shore up an endowment that has taken a beating from the pandemic and declining enrollments.

Both sides hailed the ruling, emphasizing different aspects.

“We are pleased that the judge ruled in Drew’s favor by finding the University’s surplus lands must be considered for realistic development potential. Drew University looks forward to working closely with Madison to accomplish our mutually beneficial goals,” Drew attorney John Inglesino said Monday in a statement.

Mayor Robert Conley said he was pleased the judge “affirmed our settlement, which delivers a 44-unit 100 percent housing project along with inclusionary projects that are already under way.”

Conley reiterated Madison’s willingness to work with Drew to save the Forest while addressing the school’s budgetary woes, and the borough’s housing obligation.

“We will continue to provide affordable housing, while also working to preserve the forest, the tree canopy, and the aquifer that we all rely on to provide drinking water for Madison and surrounding communities,” Conley said in a statement.

The Fair Share Housing Center also welcomed the order.

“We agree with the Judge’s decision in this case. We look forward to working with all of the stakeholders involved to figure out an appropriate plan to create more affordable homes on suitable sites in Madison, which need not be entirely on Drew’s property,” the Center said in a statement.


Drew is suing Madison, contending the municipality purposely excluded the Drew Forest–53 or 63 acres; the judge was not sure–from its calculations of open land. Drew says this enabled Madison to pare its affordable housing obligation from 500 units to 147.

The borough denies Drew’s allegation, which is moot, according to the judge, whose order stemmed from testimony at a hearing in Morristown last month.

Drew University. Photo by Louise Witt

Drew University. Photo by Louise Witt

“It only matters that the land may be available regardless of whether or not Madison intentionally failed to disclose it. It is also noted that at no time did Drew make this fact known during the compliance review period,” Hansbury wrote.

To debate the point further only would delay analysis of the Forest’s suitability for development, the judge reasoned.

Drew’s survey must depict wetlands, steep slopes, flood hazards and “any other condition that could negatively affect its development potential,” the judge wrote in his order.

Hansbury gave no deadline for Drew to complete the survey, expressing confidence the school “is sufficiently motivated to complete this process, as soon as possible.”

Towards that end, the judge granted Drew status as a “defendant-intervenor.” Environmental concerns raised by the nonprofit Friends of the Drew Forest also “must be carefully considered,” he ruled.

The Friends say the Forest is a valuable aquifer recharge area for several towns, provides habitat for many birds and a rare bat species, and offers passive recreation for a densely populated region.

The Drew Forest, August 2022. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

If some or all of the Drew Forest is found appropriate for housing, Madison must submit a revised analysis of the borough’s vacant land, and update its fair share obligation accordingly.

Yet the Drew Forest still might be spared in such a scenario, Hansbury suggested, if the borough finds “other reasonable means” to provide more affordable housing.

Lydia Chambers, co-chair of the Friends of the Drew Forest, said her group is heartened that the judge heard its arguments and “acknowledges the environmental sensitivity of this land, and is making it a central focus going forward.”

Governmental agencies and private organizations have the means to conserve the Drew Forest, Chambers said.

“There is money to buy this land, we believe.”

This story has been updated with comments from Mayor Conley.

If you’ve read this far… you clearly value your local news. Now we need your help to keep producing the local coverage you depend on! More people are reading Morristown Green than ever. But costs keep rising. Reporting the news takes time, money and hard work. We do it because we, like you, believe an informed citizenry is vital to a healthy community.

So please, CONTRIBUTE to MG or become a monthly SUBSCRIBER. ADVERTISE on Morristown Green. LIKE us on Facebook, FOLLOW us on Twitter, and SIGN UP for our newsletter.

[interactive_copyright_notice float='left']
[icopyright_horizontal_toolbar float='right']