A new flavor at the Creamery: Family sells ice cream shop after more than 20 sweet years

Ricky Manesh, new owner of the South Street Creamery, June 2022. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
1

 

For more than two decades, the South Street Creamery has been introducing sweet flavors to Morristown.

Get ready for another one: Persian ice cream.

“It’s unique,” says RezaRicky” Manesh, who has purchased the building and the business from the Garcia family.

The flavor–expressing hints of saffron, rosewater and pistachio–is one of the few tweaks planned by Manesh, who opened the Marjan Fine Persian Grill on Speedwell Avenue in 2010.

Ricky Manesh, new owner of the South Street Creamery, with longtime shop manager Elizabeth ‘Carol’ Mejia, June 2022. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

When he heard that his friend Ken Garcia was hoping to retire from the Creamery, Manesh remembers telling him: “You worked too hard for 22 years to bring it to where it is. It would be a shame if anybody came in and changed everything.”

Manesh says he plans to maintain the same sunny environment that has made the Creamery a morning gathering spot for young moms, a popular lunch stop, and a go-to place for kids’ birthday parties and Little League celebrations.

Eileen Mejia will continue to manage daily operations, with the same staff of high school- and college students who seemingly have grown up behind the counter.

Although this is Manesh’s first ice cream shop, he has made Persian ice cream at Marjan, the restaurant he named for his wife.

Ricky Manesh, owner of the Marjan Fine Persian Grill, has bought the South Street Creamery, June 2022. Don’t be surprised if menu treats soon include Persian sweets like baklava. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Manesh has confidence honed from decades as an entrepreneur and businessman after emigrating from Iran–where he was a professional volleyball player–following the 1979 revolution there.

He played volleyball in Canada for awhile, he says, and was a manager for a restaurant chain for several years.

With “$10 in my pocket” and a young family, the naturalized citizen then opened a small Madison shop, selling pagers by day and delivering pizzas for Domino’s until 1 a.m., he remembers.

In 1991, Manesh started a cell phone business in Madison. He would open AT&T franchises in East Hanover, Roxbury and downtown Morristown, keeping the latter one until 2009.

“I’m grateful to the United States,” says Manesh, who has two grown daughters and five grandkids. “Here, you can be who you want to be. Doors are open. Nothing will stop you if you try… If a pizza driver can make it, anybody can.”

‘A NICE, CLEAN, HAPPY SPACE’

The Garcias stuck around this month to smooth Manesh’s transition.

“We’re all so happy a wonderful new family has bought the business,” says Lori Ann Giardina, the smiling public face of the Creamery for its entire life.

Jeff and Lori Ann Giardina at the Creamery with sons Christian and Justin. Photo courtesy of Lori Ann Giardina

Giardina’s father, Ken Garcia, cashed in many of his AT&T shares in the late ’90s to buy the building.

“He wisely said he’d like to invest in our family,” Giardina recounts. “My dad always said he wanted a family friendly restaurant, with a nice, clean, happy space, with affordable prices. That’s what we tried to do for the entire course of our time here.”

While Ken handled the shopping, Giardina’s mom, Arlene Garcia, contributed soup recipes, baked cookies and pitched in as needed.

Giardina’s brother-in-law, Peter Williams, ventured to Italy to learn how to make gelato, and to the University of Wisconsin for schooling on homemade ice cream. Giardina’s sister Carla did a stint at the Creamery, too.

Lori Ann Giardina and Peter Williams at ‘Cones for Cancer’ fundraiser at the Creamery, December 2014. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Before opening in 1999, the family visited mom-and-pop ice cream shops all over the country, Giardina recounts. A store owner in Connecticut advised that each member should oversee one aspect of the business.

Children's author Marie Pfeifer, flanked by sisters Carla Williams and Lori ann Giardina of the South Street Creamery. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Children’s author Marie Pfeifer, flanked by sisters Carla Williams and Lori ann Giardina of the South Street Creamery. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“Whoever is in charge of that area gets the final say. That’s why it was so successful. At the very end we were all saying what a great experience this was,” says Giardina.

She enjoyed many sweet moments–readings by children’s authors, ukulele jam sessions, visits by Santa–and some bittersweet ones, at the Creamery.

It’s where she met her husband Jeff, the love of her life. And it’s where the community rallied around them both when he bravely fought a terminal form of cancer.

Lori Ann Giardina photographs crowd at ‘Cones for Cancer’ fundraiser, Dec. 5, 2014. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Giardina looks forward to more time with her sons Justin and Christian, a high schooler who still works at the Creamery. And her parents will get a chance to retire for real.

“They would never stop going in if Peter and I were there,” Giardina says. “We needed to all retire at the same time.”

A young listener gets laugh from Arlene Pfeifer and her mom, author Marie Pfeifer, at the Creamery. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
A young listener gets laugh from Arlene Pfeifer and her mom, author Marie Pfeifer, at the Creamery. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

If you’ve read this far… you clearly value your local news. Now we need your help to keep producing the local coverage you depend on! More people are reading Morristown Green than ever. But costs keep rising. Reporting the news takes time, money and hard work. We do it because we, like you, believe an informed citizenry is vital to a healthy community.

So please, CONTRIBUTE to MG or become a monthly SUBSCRIBER. ADVERTISE on Morristown Green. LIKE us on Facebook, FOLLOW us on Twitter, and SIGN UP for our newsletter.

1 COMMENT

  1. What a wonderful success story! The Creamery has been one of favorite spots in town for many years.

LEAVE A REPLY