Morris School District bids emotional farewell to Pendergrast; parents challenge grading policy

Departing Supt. Mackey Pendergrast addresses MSD board one last time, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin


The Morris School District bade an emotional farewell to retiring Superintendent Mackey Pendergrast on Monday, at a board meeting where parents also sharply questioned district policies on grades and vaccination requirements for volunteers.

MSG Board President Melissa Spiotta chokes back tears during farewell to Supt. Mackey Pendergrast, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“As Glinda said to Elphaba in the musical Wicked, you came into our lives for a reason, bringing something that we must learn so we could grow, as a district. And grow we certainly did,” said board President Melissa Spiotta, choking back tears.

Pendergrast was lionized for the district’s rising academic performance, for his commitment to diversity, and for keeping some classrooms open when many other districts closed during the pandemic.

“How lucky have we been,” said board member Nancy Bangiola. 

Board Vice President Nancy Bangiola, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

This is the superintendent’s final week. His predecessor, Thomas Ficarra, returns as an interim while the board seeks a permanent hire.

There were good wishes from a music teacher, and from the Morris Educational Foundation, a nonprofit that underwrites programs in the K-12 district, which serves a diverse mix of 5,700 pupils from Morristown, Morris Township and (for high school) Morris Plains.

Former board President Leonard Posey, now a Miami resident, brought kudos and a toy Porsche for Pendergrast, hired on his watch in 2015.

Former MSD board president Len Posey presents toy car to departing Supt. Mackey Pendergrast, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“You have been a true gift to this district,” Margaret Monahan, past president of a home school association (known elsewhere as the PTA), told Pendergrast.

“It’s not fair at all that he’s leaving before my children have all graduated,” joked Jean Jabbour, who knew Pendergrast when he ran Mendham’s schools.

“There was definitely a comfort and a security in knowing that you were in charge, and I’m sad to see you go.”


Pendergrast didn’t get every decision right. But he always put students first, said Mark Maire, superintendent of the Morris Plains K-8 district.

It was an especially heavy responsibility in a pandemic.

“Last year was probably the hardest year of our lives. But what you did was you got kids in school every day, and when you look to see what other districts did, I’m grateful that my children were here,” Maire said.

Departing MSD Supt. Mackey Pendergrast and MSD Board President Melissa Spiotta, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Berit Ollestad.

“We didn’t choose this position to be in the limelight. We didn’t choose this position to be fan favorites. We chose it because we wanted to make a difference. You did,” he told Pendergrast.

Nobody thinks this New Jersey Superintendent of the Year will stay retired for long. What’s next for Pendergrast?

“That’s a good question. Hopefully, he’ll try cooking!” said his wife Andrea. They met as young history teachers. “We had hall duty,” she said.

“I’m a lucky man. I’m a blessed person, because of Andrea,” Pendergrast said, thanking his spouse for understanding the 24-7 demands of his job.

His brief farewell remarks followed an overview of the district’s progress. He thanked parents for pushing him to do more for “marginalized kids,” praised the teachers’ union for honest disagreements, and cited laughter and tears shared with his central office team.

“They mean everything to me,” he said.

Departing MSD Supt. Mackey Pendergrast listens to good wishes from Board Member Linda Murphy, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

When the board interviewed Pendergrast in 2014, someone inquired what he was reading. Anthony Doerr’s novel All the Light We Cannot See is set in a Nazi-occupied French town in World War II. Coming full circle, Pendergrast drew an analogy to the district’s educational philosophy.

Morristown High orchestra performs at MSD board meeting,Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“There is so much goodness in the world, so many positive powerful things out there, so many things that lead to a person’s life being made full and purposeful,” he said.

Academic success, he suggested, stems from a myriad of unseen factors–parents reading to their young children, teachers feverishly grading papers on nights and weekends, “hard conversations” with the board.

Add it all up, he seemed to be saying, and you get the Morris School District.

“This is a great place to be if you want to do great things,” Pendergrast said.


Robust discussion is part of that equation, of course, and the superintendent got an earful on his way out.

Parent Michele Cottone questions MSD board, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Michele Cottone, president of the Sussex Avenue School parents’ association, questioned vaccine mandates for parents who wish to volunteer at school Halloween parties.

That’s stricter than what’s required of teachers, who can submit to COVID-19 testing as an alternative to inoculation, Cottone said. “We’re not being treated equally,” she said.

Parents also gave failing marks to a new grading system. It attempts to standardize grades –making an A an A across all disciplines and classes–and pegs semester grades mostly to a final “summative” test meant to show subject mastery.

Brian Young, MSD Director of Curriculum, addresses board, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

District Curriculum Director Brian Young said the Frelinghuysen Middle School has been moving toward this for awhile, and Chatham and Livingston schools adopted similar policies a few years ago.

The district contends this policy aligns more closely with college grading systems.

But parent Scott Wild, a math teacher for 30 years in Newark, said it does not align with grading at the University of Southern California, where his son is a sophomore.

And his kids’ teachers in the Morris district “have no idea what the policy is supposed to be.”

Parent Ken Gustavsen addresses MSD board, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Wild said the district is minimizing the value of homework and class discussion. There are no incentives for either, he said, when a “summative” exam carries far more weight than “formative” studies that precede it.

Another parent, Ken Gustavsen, said one of his children, a high school sophomore, was stressing out because 90 percent of his grade rests on one exam.

“That’s a big deal,” he said, above the loud hum of an air purifier in a Morristown High School auditorium that would resemble a cave — if it had more light and fewer echoes.

Departing Supt. Mackey Pendergrast addresses MSD board one last time, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Gustavsen’s middle-schooler feels no need to do math homework, the parent added, because teachers aren’t grading it. So the student’s flawed approach to problem-solving went undetected, and uncorrected, for a long time.

“It’s just not working,” Gustavsen said of the new policy.

Attributing parents’ concerns to “confusion over vocabulary and words,” Pendergrast said “there needs to be a lot more clarity” from the district.

But that’s for another day. And another superintendent.

Hope Summerset-Neely, Leonard Posey and departing MSD Supt. Mackey Pendergrast, Oct. 25, 2021. Photo by Berit Ollestad

If you’ve read this far… you clearly value your local news. Now we need your help to keep producing the local coverage you depend on! More people are reading Morristown Green than ever. But costs keep rising. Reporting the news takes time, money and hard work. We do it because we, like you, believe an informed citizenry is vital to a healthy community.

So please, CONTRIBUTE to MG or become a monthly SUBSCRIBER. ADVERTISE on Morristown Green. LIKE us on Facebook, FOLLOW us on Twitter, and SIGN UP for our newsletter.

[interactive_copyright_notice float='left']
[icopyright_horizontal_toolbar float='right']


  1. @school choice: the article says it’s for parent volunteers at school events, not parents generally. To your point that “no other district is like this”, do you mean that no other district follows state mandates COVID protocols?

    @kidsneedhomework: you “feel” like the district competitiveness has gone down since he got here, but literally every metric says the opposite. Where’s the feeling coming from?

  2. @schoolchoice the article mentions parents who are volunteering at the school, not parents generally. What would be a more cost effective way to keep kids safe: call on the probably 70+ percent of parents who are vaccinated on their own dime to volunteer, or pay for testing for the volunteers? Also, to “no other district is like this”, are you saying that no other district follows the laws related to COVID restrictions?

    @kidsneedhomework, you “feel” the districts competitiveness has gone down, but you see that every metric of competitiveness indicates otherwise?

  3. So I am hearing now that class room parents who are willing to share their vaccination status to attend their child’s Halloween party are being told they cannot come at all!!!! Everyone is too busy for class parents to help! Is this in retaliation for parents speaking up at the BOE meeting??? Is this the last ‘stick it to you all’ by Mackey??!! Disgraceful!!! Vote for BOE members who won’t be bobble heads and agree to everything!!!! Vote for Dawn Parkot!! Vote for JACK!!! We need a better NJ NOW!!! End these stupid Executive Orders!!!!

  4. @Kevin, is the district really mandating vaccines for parents? Where is this posted? I have never heard of such a thing! Sounds like a lawsuit waiting to happen! Why is the district hell-bent on making school a prison, NO OTHER DISTRICT IS LIKE THIS!

    I agree the new grading policy is awful, the teachers can’t even explain it!

    Hope the new super can turn things around and stop the insanity!

  5. So every positive comment was someone on the payroll who was invited to be there? Interesting. And of course no parent concerns were addressed but let’s watch another mind numbing power point! I feel the district’s competitiveness has gone down during Mackey’s tenure. We are showing ourselves to be weak-if you need more evidence look at Tuesday’s 2 hour delay, FOR RAIN!!!