Golden opportunity for Gilded Age relic? Morris Township to weigh posh proposal for the Abbey

Artist's rendering of proposed Restoration Hardware plan for the Abbey in Morris Township.
6

 

By Marion Filler and Kevin Coughlin

 

The Abbey, one of Morris Township’s last mansions from the Gilded Age, is poised for a rebirth.

Restoration Hardware, the upscale home furnishing chain now known as RH, is making a pitch to the Township Committee to transform the Madison Avenue manor into a glamorous showroom, restaurant, and wine bar.

The Abbey in Morris Township.

A planning board meeting is scheduled for Monday, April 6, 2020, at 7:30 pm, and a special session of the Committee is set for April 29.

Both meetings hinge on whether remote presentations can be arranged to include public participation, Mayor Cathy Wilson said on Thursday. Public gatherings are prohibited because of the coronavirus pandemic.

“The Abbey has been vacant for years. It’s a beautiful, historic structure that many people (including me) would love to preserve and re-purpose. Doing so is easier said than done. Several attempts over the years have failed,” Wilson said in a message to the community.

Restoration Hardware became interested in 2017 after seeing the Abbey, also known as Alnwick Hall, featured by Mansion in May, a month-long fundraiser for Morristown Medical Center, according to owner Tom Maoli.

A redevelopment plan was submitted to the Township Committee last month. The Township declared the Abbey an area in need of redevelopment in September 2018.

Maoli, owner of Celebrity Motors, bought the 42-room Renaissance Revival mansion for $6.25 million in 2008.

Abbey owner Tom Maoliat Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Abbey owner Tom Maoliat Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“The design of the building was absolutely stunning, a castle. I wanted to be king of my castle,” said the Mendham resident, who intended to make the Abbey his office.

But heating, air conditioning and maintaining the massive structure proved daunting. Records show taxes topped $62,000 last year.

Maoli considered a housing development for the six-acre site, and he applied for a demolition permit.

He also conducted an online survey of residents. More than 500 responded that they favored saving the Abbey, he said.

“The Restoration Hardware plan is spectacular,” Maoli said. “It saves the grandeur of the the site, and will be the pinnacle of Morris Township. This will put Morris Township on the map… I think it’s a win-win for this town, and for the people and the history of the town.”

The building fronts Madison Avenue, and except for removing a narrow portion in the back, its exterior will remain intact.

This rear area of the Abbey would be removed in the redevelopment plan proposed by Restoration Hardware.

Two main additions are planned: A two-story showroom to the right side of the original building that runs parallel to Madison Avenue, as well as a restaurant and wine bar on the far rear of the property, midway between the two buildings.

Diners will be surrounded by gardens and a patio used to display RH outdoor furniture.

Restoration Hardware CEO Gary Friedman, 62, likes to call his stores “galleries.” According to Forbes, the mall-sized stores ranging between 6,000 and 10,000 square feet gradually are being phased out in favor of large, free-standing buildings between 46,000- and 90,000 square feet.

Grandiose showrooms, many with restaurants, are in Chicago, West Palm Beach, Nashville, Toronto, New York, and Yountville.

Video: Restoration Hardware in New York:

How does the 21,000-square-foot Abbey fit into this picture? It’s part of a strategy to supplement the over-the-top urban approach for which RH has become well known. Friedman now is opening smaller galleries in affluent areas and second home markets such as the Hamptons, Palm Beach, and soon in Aspen, with products tailored to local tastes.

Whether large or small, selling furniture in an RH gallery is deliberately incidental to experiencing a lifestyle — and then being seduced by it.

Luxurious monochrome interiors loaded with texture are essential to the look. Linen, leather, fiber, chunky wood and a general lack of pattern, are combined with slightly oversized furniture to bring it all home.

Sales are always the bottom line, so the expectation is that after having a great meal and a glass of wine at an RH restaurant, you will be enticed to buying a chair or two — or more — before you leave.

Video: RH in West Palm:

According to Variety, Friedman just purchased a $37 million dollar mansion in Bel Air, and now lives in the style of his own creation. However, his early life was anything but affluent.

His father died when Friedman was just 5 years old and he was raised by a single mother on welfare who battled mental illness. They moved 16 times by the time Friedman was 18.

Gary Friedman, CEO of Restoration Hardware. Photo: RestorationHardware.com

He dropped out of Santa Rosa College and found a job stocking shelves at the Gap. Rising to a managerial position, he did well enough to be recruited by Williams Sonoma, where he stayed for 13 years.

When passed over for the presidency, he moved to Restoration Hardware, which was struggling with debt and badly in need of a new image. He was exactly what the company needed.

Though a series of high stakes moves including stock buybacks, Friedman turned the company around and made his fortune along the way.

After some personal problems including a divorce and accusations of improper behavior with an employee 30 years his junior, he left Restoration Hardware, only to be rehired nine months later and increase sales to record levels.

The Abbey, temporarily redesigned for Mansion in May 2017. Slideshow photos by Kevin Coughlin; hover over image for captions.

Jennifer Lewicki and Judi Schwarz of Judi Schwarz Interiors in their 'Homework Haven' (space 34), with artwork by National Merit Scholar Jacob Schuster of Old Tappan, at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Decorator Elizabeth Guest looks for spaces that 'spark something. Then I go home and the ideas start flowing in, like Tetris. Click, click, click,' she said at Mansion in May 2017, space 14. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Michael Chutko prefers selling pop art to his former gig, as owner of Don's Burgers and Fries in Morristown. 'One's a terrible grind; the other's pure passion and pleasure,' he said at Mansion in May 2017 (Space 27). Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Kathy Borenstein, R.N., says a nursing center funded by Mansion in May 2017 will 'tease out new innovations and new practices, providing better care and helping nurses grow, professionally and personally.' Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Richard Barr of Plumberry Design has co-created 'The Left Bank Loft' (space 15) at Mansion in May 2017. 'I do it for the love of design...and to give back to the hospital,' he says. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
'Imagine yourself having lunch looking over Mediterranean waters,' says Kristin Ashley Badolato, who created the 'Cafe Hyacinth' (space 39) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Sculpture by Jean Kawecki, presented by Broadfoot & Broadfoot in space 7 at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
'This is a labor of love,' says Sue Bruen (operations), far right, with other key volunteers at Mansion in May 2017. From left: Jean O'Toole (publicity), Kim Lopez (website), Barbara Gallo (publicity), Corinne Nallet and Jeanne Finn (landscaping), Sue Bruen. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Landscaper Bruce Davies with waterfall created for Mansion in May 2017. Hundreds of laborers created 17 gardens; the most intense activity was late April, Bruce says. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Artists in Residence (space 36) at Mansion in May 2017: Southpaw John Puglionisi, a retired advertising guy from Morristown, and Chester righty Valerie Verona, a veteran of several Mansions in May. They're donating 15 percent of their art sales to the hospital. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
DeVoe & Angel Martin of Affordable Closets Plus in Bangor, PA, designed a 'woman's cave' (space 30) at Mansion in May 2017. 'The exposure is phenomenal,' says Angel, a veteran of four Mansion in May events. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Melissa McNamara and Sarah Conine of Garden Cottage have created an inviting game room (space 32) that includes patio furniture, at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Chelsea Taylor of Edward Clark Landscape Architect firm in a temporary garden at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Morris Township Mayor Bruce Sisler and Morristown First Lady Mary Dougherty explore Mansion in May 2017. 'It's noble...absolutely beautiful,' says Sisler. Dougherty, a realtor, can't wait to show clients. 'It looked so dark and dingy before. Now, it's light and brightness,' she says. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
From left: Co-chair Megan Cassie Schubiger, Morristown First Lady Mary Dougherty, Morris Township Administrator Tim Quinn, Twp. Mayor Bruce Sisler, and co-chair Katie Nolle, at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Bedminster decorator Sagri Frieber, a Honduran immigrant, 'kneeled down here and asked God for direction' before designing 'The Believer's War Room,' a meditation space (N. 18) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Lakshmi Sheth of Cabri Inc. in Summit helped re-make the kitchen at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
The Toy Tamer: Evelyn Cucchiara made this playroom (space 35) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Nancy Coutts and Katja van der Loo borrowed a violin from a music store as centerpiece of 'Rosalie's Music Room' (space 26) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
'The biggest challenge is finding the mansion' every few years, says Kathy Hobbs, publicity chair for Mansion in May 2017. Some 18 committees of the hospital Woman's Association oversee more than 1,300 volunteers, and chose about 45 decorators and landscapers from 270 who submit their ideas. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Bob Rybski and Joe Turner have re-created a British street corner pub, dubbed Abbey Road (space 33) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Bedminster designer Kristen Vander Ploeg of Design Consultants, helped reinvent an office (space 19) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Jill Guzman and Anne Lynch of Olcott Square Interiors designed space 28 at Mansion in May 2017. 'Each room has a distinct personality,' Jill says. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Kathleen Palmer of the Studio 7 Fine Art Gallery in Bernardsville with Gerry Heydt painting of The Abbey, at Mansion in May 2017, space 13. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Wendy Scott of Sophisticated Storage Solutions has created a crafts room (space 37) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Karen Casella and Michelle Gonella of Re-Feather Your Nest converted a bathroom into a college student hideaway (space 23) at Mansion in May 2017. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
previous arrow
next arrow
PlayPause
Shadow
Slider

Replete with 15th- and 16th century affectations inspired by Alnwick Castle in Northumberland, England, the Abbey was built in 1904 for Edward P. Meany, director of American Telephone and Telegraph, as one of the grandest estates along Millionaire’s Row.

The stretch of Madison Avenue from Morristown to Madison attracted Vanderbilts, Rockefellers and other New York captains of industry around the turn of the 20th century.

Many great singers from that era gave concerts at Alnwick Hall, hosted by Meany’s wife Rosalie. Renowned violinist Efrem Zimbalist met famed soprano Alma Gluck en route to one such soirée; they married, and their son, Efrem Zimbalist Jr. became a TV star.

Natural state: How the Abbey looked before Mansion in May. Slideshow photos by Berit Ollestead

Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
Mansion in May preview, Feb. 1, 2017. Photo by Berit Ollestad
previous arrow
next arrow
PlayPause
Shadow
Slider

 

The Abbey has been on the State and National Historic Register since 1985.

Its many owners and tenants over the last century included St. Mark’s Lutheran Church, there for nearly a quarter century until 1984, and offices and medical services.

Carol Barkin of the local Historic Preservation Commission described the Abbey as “one of the most distinctive properties in Morris Township,” adding: “We are encouraged that there is a realistic plan to save it. We believe residents will be in favor of it too.”

Monday’s planning board session, if it happens, will address whether the Abbey redevelopment plan complies with the Township’s zoning master plan.

It’s possible the Township Committee could approve the redevelopment plan on April 29, after hearing public comments, Wilson said.

If the plan is approved, the matter would return to the planning board for site plan approval, a process likely to take several meetings. Residents would have more opportunities to weigh in as those deliberations unfold, the mayor said.

MORE ABOUT 2017 MANSION IN MAY AT THE ABBEY

Aerial view of proposed Restoration Hardware redevelopment of the Abbey in Morris Township.

If you’ve read this far… you clearly value your local news. Now we need your help to keep producing the local coverage you depend on! More people are reading Morristown Green than ever. But costs keep rising. Reporting the news takes time, money and hard work. We do it because we, like you, believe an informed citizenry is vital to a healthy community.

So please, CONTRIBUTE to MG or become a monthly SUBSCRIBER. ADVERTISE on Morristown Green. LIKE us on Facebook, FOLLOW us on Twitter, and SIGN UP for our newsletter.

[interactive_copyright_notice float='left']
[icopyright_horizontal_toolbar float='right']

6 COMMENTS

  1. Phenomenal project and great use of a historic property. It’s a shame that a concept like this wasn’t championed for the former Greystone property.

    There are some very intelligent people running Morris Township and I have confidence they will not let this opportunity pass.

  2. RH has done amazing adaptive reuse projects all over the country. The closest one is NYC in the meatpacking district with a roof-top restaurant. Other projects are in Nashville, West Palm, Chicago, West Hollywood, Atlanta, Columbus, Minneapolis, and Toronto. RH.com for videos of their historic preservation projects. Thank you, RH, for looking at Morris Township and the Abbey.

  3. Having grown up in Morris Township, I am excited that the township is considering an application by Restoration Hardware to re-purpose and preserve The Abbey/Alnwick Hall on Madison Avenue. I have already seen far too many mansions demolished along this street. Morris Township now has before it the opportunity to save one of the best and most recognized examples on what was once Millionaire’s Row. I ask that you give this proposal serious consideration to bring an upscale retailer to the area, as well as to preserve a local gem and historic landmark at the same time.

LEAVE A REPLY