Morristown council continues battle with Iron Bar, approves creation of public safety director

Jimmy Cavanaugh, owner of the Iron Bar and Revolution, listens as the Morristown council re-imposes conditions on his liquor license, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Jimmy Cavanaugh, owner of the Iron Bar and Revolution, listens as the Morristown council re-imposes conditions on his liquor license, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Morristown’s council was busy on Tuesday, agreeing to add a public safety director to oversee the police and fire departments, and reimposing last-call curfews in a long-running feud with the Iron Bar.

Council members also introduced an ordinance to update the town’s zoning codes, and gave themselves and the mayor modest raises.

And the governing body officially adopted a $52.4 million municipal budget for 2018, as expected, while scrapping a measure that would have reduced liability insurance for taxi drivers in town.

Morristown Police Chief Pete Demnitz at Morristown March for Our Lives, March 24, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Morristown Police Chief Pete Demnitz at Morristown March for Our Lives, March 24, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Officials said the hiring of a public safety director–at a salary of $100,000 to $150,000–is not in response to Police Chief Pete Demnitz losing a lawsuit last month to a whistleblowing officer who successfully argued he was demoted unfairly.

A jury slapped Morristown with $1.7 million in damages in that trial, a verdict the town has not yet decided whether to appeal.

“Our police chief and our fire chief do a great job. But sometimes things fall through the cracks,” Council President Toshiba Foster said after the 6-0 vote to create a public safety department. “Having a public safety director adds another layer of protection, another layer for Morristown residents to feel safe.”

“It’s not a retaliation” for the lawsuit, town Attorney Vij Pawar said of the new position. “I don’t think one has anything to do with the other.”

Demnitz and Fire Chief Robert Flanagan could not be reached for comment Tuesday night.

A public safety director is necessary because the chiefs are “inundated” with daily responsibilities that hinder big-picture planning and interdepartmental coordination, town Administrator Jillian Barrick told the council.

She noted Morristown is a magnet for activists; thousands came this year for the Women’s March and the March for Our Lives. President Trump flies regularly from Morristown Airport, and his security requires cooperation between police and the Secret Service. Morris County offices are here, along with a bustling downtown, a large hospital and the Morris School District.

In recent years, the town also has been slammed by powerful storms.

All these things place heavy demands on town cops and firemen, Barrick indicated.

A public safety director, to be hired by Mayor Tim Dougherty, will help the chiefs “leverage the existing resources that we have, so we can do even more for public safety,” she said.

According to the ordinance, scheduled for adoption on June 26, 2018, the public safety director must have 10 years of experience in law enforcement, firefighting or public safety, and five of those years must be in a supervisory role. Those stipulations may be waived with a two-thirds vote by the council.

Reporting to Barrick, the director will be “responsible for the administration, regulation and discipline of the Bureau of Police Protection, the Bureau of Fire Protection, and Emergency Management,” the ordinance states.

Duties will include formulating plans, policies, procedures and staffing recommendations; creating performance criteria and conducting evaluations; conducting public relations and public information programs; serving as liaison to town agencies and officials; assisting in emergency preparedness and seeking disaster recovery grants; and reporting annually to town officials about the state of police, fire and emergency management operations.

Foster said she hopes the administration will hire the director by late summer.


Without discussion, the council voted 5-0 to re-impose early closing times on the Revolution beer hall as a condition of its annual liquor license renewal.

“Wait till you see the suit we’re going to drop on them,” vowed Jimmy Cavanaugh, owner of Revolution and the adjoining Iron Bar, which share a license. He claimed the vote was planned secretly, violating the state’s Sunshine Law.

Bar attorney Robert C. Williams, no stranger to the council, advocates for the Iron Bar and Revolution, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Bar attorney Robert C. Williams, no stranger to the council, advocates for the Iron Bar and Revolution, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

Cavanaugh’s attorney, Robert C. Williams, had pressed council members to state their reasons for insisting Revolution close at 11 pm Sundays through Thursdays, and at 11:30 pm on Fridays and Saturdays. Other bars on South Street can stay open until 2 am.

“It’s totally unfair to continue this any longer,” Williams said.

He cited an administrative law judge’s decision urging the state to make Morristown rescind the “arbitrary, capricious, unreasonable and discriminatory” curfews, which have been stayed four times by the state Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control since Revolution opened in 2014, according to Williams.

Revolution and the Iron Bar have not been cited for any violations, he said. Town officials–including the police- and fire chief and council president at the time–testified last year that they found no specific problems with Revolution, he said. More than 1,000 people, by his count, have signed a petition opposing early closings.

All the legal wrangling has cost Cavanaugh, a former Essex County freeholder, about $100,000 in attorney fees, Williams asserted.

But South Street suffers from an “over-saturation” of bars, Foster told Morristown Green after the meeting.

“The council position is to protect the quality of life for residents of that district,” said the council president.

Pawar, the town attorney, said the judge who issued the opinion was not the same judge who conducted last year’s two-day hearing. Morristown’s appeal is pending before the state ABC commissioner, he said.

The Sunshine Law was not violated on Tuesday, Pawar said. “There was nothing addressed behind closed doors. We didn’t have an executive session today. The vote was a public vote.”

First-year Councilman David Silva abstained, explaining later that he was not familiar enough with the situation. Councilwoman Alison Deeb, mourning the death of her father, was absent.


An ordinance introduced unanimously aims to simplify town zoning, so fewer property owners will need costly variances before making home improvements.

Some residents actually have moved away rather than endure that onerous process, town Planner Phil Abramson said during his council presentation.

The ordinance is meant to implement goals of the town’s 2014 master plan. It closes zoning loopholes and is sensitive to residents’ concerns about overly dense development, Abramson said.

Town Planner Phil Abramson makes point during zoning presentation, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin
Town Planner Phil Abramson makes point during zoning presentation, June 12, 2018. Photo by Kevin Coughlin

“What we heard loud and clear is preserve the identity and integrity of neighborhoods,” he said.

The measure draws upon Abramson’s review of variances stretching back a decade.

Among other things, it knocks one story off the present maximum building height of six stories, in most locations.

It also enables shared parking by residential units and office buildings, removes prohibitions against placing apartments above retail establishments, eliminates most conditional uses, and cuts confusing zone designations by half.

Reciting Joyce Kilmer’s poem Trees, resident Margret Brady urged the council to create a park in her heavily developed Franklin Corners neighborhood in memory of Kilmer, a onetime Hill Street resident killed in World War I.

Town officials are looking to preserve open space in the First Ward, Councilman Bob Iannaccone assured her.

The zoning ordinance is a work in progress. Two residents who live near Morristown High School came to the council with concerns that fast-food joints now would be allowed in their neighborhood.

Councilman Stefan Armington said he spoke with town planners earlier in the day to remove that piece from the ordinance.

It’s scheduled for a once-over by the planning board on June 21, and a public hearing at the June 26 council meeting.

Another ordinance had attempted to help licensed taxi companies compete with Uber and Lyft, by lowering the taxis’ insurance coverage for passengers to the minimum of $35,000 per accident.

Iannaccone, CEO of a Newark Hospital, spoke against it. “I’ll go on record: $35,000 is irresponsible,” he said.

Councilman Michael Elms agreed, saying he changed his mind since the measure’s introduction. While its intentions were noble, “$35,000 is like a broken arm at the hospital,” he said. The ordinance was rejected unanimously.

Mayor Tim Dougherty proposed 1.75 percent raises for himself and the council, to bring his part-time yearly pay to $26,498 and council members to $9,845, with an extra $1,000 for Foster as council president.

“Since I’ve been elected there has not been any increase over the eight years. It’s minimal, in line with the nonunion employees…and you deserve it,” Dougherty said.

The council concurred, introducing the salary ordinance without dissent.

If you’ve read this far… you clearly value your local news. Now we need your help to keep producing the local coverage you depend on! More people are reading Morristown Green than ever. But costs keep rising. Reporting the news takes time, money and hard work. We do it because we, like you, believe an informed citizenry is vital to a healthy community.

So please, CONTRIBUTE to MG or become a monthly SUBSCRIBER. ADVERTISE on Morristown Green. LIKE us on Facebook, FOLLOW us on Twitter, and SIGN UP for our newsletter.

[interactive_copyright_notice float='left']
[icopyright_horizontal_toolbar float='right']


  1. Again the state ABC has ruled in iron bars favor, the mayor and council continue to waste taxpayers $$$ for this personal mission to hurt our small business. This is a group that has contributed nothing of meaning in their quest for power.

  2. It’s all about political donations, weather you own a business or want to develop, morristown is for sale. Dougherty keeps this lawsuit with iron bar going to feed legal fees to his political allies. Dougherty and his puppets on the council have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars arguing weather revolution should stay open an additional 2 hours. This is personal as you will see shortly.

  3. I so agree, what we need is less intense development with ugly high rise buildings and now the mayor continues to push for storage units on Morris Ave…we already have way too much traffic; and now the mayor is trying to take spaces away from the parking lot at the corner of Elm and South which so many people use to walk to local nearby small restaurants and businesses. and the parking would go to tenants of Callaloo when it is torn down….quite a walk….why is the mayor apparently in favor of every developer that has a proposal for Morristown?…never hear him talk about protecting residential Morristown and our quality of life…

  4. A public safety director is a waste of money! It’s another attempt by mayor Tim to control the pd.

  5. Town attorney Pawar stated there were no meetings on the subject of hours for revolution, no discussion took place at the meeting prior to the vote. So how did a resolution appear with restricted hours ? I guess the council has perfected mind reading. More taxpayer money being spent on a personal agenda.

  6. I’m trying very hard to understand the decision by the Council re limiting the hours of the Iron Bar. But it goes against my sense of logic and fairness.

    It’s not enough to say: “The council’s position is to protect the quality of life for residents of that district” when additional licenses are being granted to others. We deserve a better explanation and need to know that all are being treated fairly.

  7. A public safety director for a police and department that combined arent even near 200 people…waste of money. And this town doesnt need anymore useless politicians

  8. Council talks about over saturation of bars on South St. then approved expansion of the Office, Tashmoo, and adds a hotel with another bar, and is about to approve the place to place transfer of the callaloo liquor license to the same area. No wonder the judge cited discrimination.